Land and food systems in times of crisis: towards fair and sustainable transformations | Land Portal

This session focussed on the transition towards more sustainable food systems in light of the upcoming UN Food Systems Summit. Four presenters shared their work, mostly from sub-Saharan Africa, and their recommendations towards more fair and sustainable production of food, as well as recommendation to change the way we think about food.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Any intervention that aims to increase food production or address food security should be rooted in the community.
  • Current framing of Africa and farmers has helped to legitimate global hierarchies and Western, expert-led interventions.
  • Policies and interventions that address women should be based on locality-specific knowledge, that includes nuances such as the interactions between women and men in that locality as well as women’s interactions with each other.
  • ‘Bold actions’ as announced by the food systems summit raise questions. Should we not intervene less and ensure more anti-colonial action that allows for farmers to lead the development process?

 

Mapping Farmer-led irrigation development (FLID) in Africa, examining FLID through a Remote Sensing Lens and how this influences interpretation and engagement
Wouter Beekman, Wageningen University and Resilience BV

  • Technology-driven interventions and policy interventionsoften undermine farmer-led innovations in the global South – disregarding farmer-led initiatives. Remote sensing is often used to map irrigation, but is also often contested. This raises more fundamental questions: what is a good development trajectory?

“We should focus on what kind of systems farmers like to develop.” 

- Wouter Beekman (Wageningen University / Resilience)

 

Landing a better deal? Women negotiating access to land and water for farming in the context of a Dutch-supported gender-inclusive water-productivity project in Mozambique

Isabella Schultz – Utrecht University

  • Old discourse and framing of women as farmers (being vulnerable and marginalised) still shape many developmental projects today. Women are not a heterogenous group and interventions should better fit local contexts.

“We should better understand the nuances of gender.”

– Bella Schultz, arguing for a more explicit recognition of women’s strategies to access land and other natural resources.

 

Decolonising communication in food security interventions in Sub-Saharan Africa? Towards sustainable and fair policies and interventions

Janwillem Liebrand, Utrecht University

We should decolonise framing of farmers as ‘primitive’ and ‘marginalised’, as is often done in policy-research debates as a remnant of colonialism.

 

“Instead of problematizing farmer-led innovation, we should start to problematise expert-led innovation and build on existing innovation of farmers”

– Janwillem Liebrand.

 

Inclusive Agribusiness and local food security findings from the Follow the Food project

Guus van Westen, LANDac / Utrecht University

  • Interventions aimed at inclusive business models tend to favour the better-off farmers and are not inclusive of the poor and smaller farmers. Furthermore, they often clash with local realities.

“Business-led development strategies are not supported by our findings”

– Guus van Westen.